[Drbd-dev] history uuids misaligned within device_statistics
David Butterfield
dab21774 at gmail.com
Wed Jun 5 17:57:32 CEST 2019
While playing with DRBD I've noticed a few things I'll mention here.
I already pointed out the problem that was most clearly a bug (indexing drbd_genl_ops by command number).
I'll put most of these comments into separate e-mail messages to facilitate their separate dispositions.
Regards,
David Butterfield
-----
The history_uuids in the device_statistics are 64 bits wide, but they are defined as a
__bin_field which does not align to a 64-bit boundary. The history_uuids field follows a 32-bit
field and is always 64-bit MIS-aligned.
This leads to a misaligned access at runtime during a "drbdsetup attach" command. On x86 the
misaligned access will work (for non-atomic operations), but not as fast as an aligned access.
Other architectures may produce a runtime fault.
In drbd_nl.c:
257 GENL_struct(DRBD_NLA_DEVICE_STATISTICS, 20, device_statistics,
258 __u64_field(1, 0, dev_size) /* (sectors) */
259 __u64_field(2, 0, dev_read) /* (sectors) */
260 __u64_field(3, 0, dev_write) /* (sectors) */
261 __u64_field(4, 0, dev_al_writes) /* activity log writes (count) */
262 __u64_field(5, 0, dev_bm_writes) /* bitmap writes (count) */
263 __u32_field(6, 0, dev_upper_pending) /* application requests in progress */
264 __u32_field(7, 0, dev_lower_pending) /* backing device requests in progress */
265 __flg_field(8, 0, dev_upper_blocked)
266 __flg_field(9, 0, dev_lower_blocked)
267 __flg_field(10, 0, dev_al_suspended) /* activity log suspended */
268 __u64_field(11, 0, dev_exposed_data_uuid)
269 __u64_field(12, 0, dev_current_uuid)
270 __u32_field(13, 0, dev_disk_flags)
271 //XXX This misaligns the 64-bit history_uuids, leading to misaligned CPU access
272 __bin_field(14, 0, history_uuids, HISTORY_UUIDS * sizeof(__u64))
273 )
drbd_nl.c:5089:21: runtime error: store to misaligned address 0x7f82417efffc for type 'u64', which requires 8 byte alignment
0x7f82417efffc: note: pointer points here
00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
^
More information about the drbd-dev
mailing list